The Edmonds City Council on Tuesday, Jan. 6 in Edmonds, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
EVERETT — The Edmonds City Council unanimously approved a moratorium on development near Deer Creek on Tuesday following code changes that have raised difficulties for processing permits.
Councilmember Susan Paine, center, makes a point about the critical areas ordinance during a Q&A with staff Tuesday night.
Key takeaways:
Michelle Dotsch elected council president, Jenna Nand selected president pro tem.
Numerous residents testify in support of a measure they say would better protect the Deer Creek critical aquifer recharge area (CARA) — and council approves it 4-3.
Councilmembers sworn in and last year’s council president gets a sendoff.
Council votes to increase the city’s transportation impact fees.
EDMONDS — The Edmonds Environmental Council and Olympic View Water & Sewer District have raised concerns regarding revisions to the city’s Critical Areas Ordinance, warning that a delay in updating policy surrounding underground stormwater wells could cause the city drinking water to become contaminated.
On July 18, 2025, the Edmonds Environmental Council (EEC) hosted a workshop at the Port of Edmonds to discuss how the organization should engage with the City of Edmonds. Participants expressed concern that the City was not adequately advancing the Critical Areas Ordinance (CAO) update required by the end of 2025. Based on that discussion, the EEC decided to engage constructively.
We have a serious human health issue brewing in Edmonds at the Deer Creek CARA (Critical Aquifer Recharge Area), which provides drinking water to south Edmonds, Woodway, and Esperance. The issue is accommodating potential development instead of avoiding contaminating our drinking water with PFAS – a pervasive, forever chemical known to have serious human health effects.
Believe it or not, the City actually wants to allow new development to inject potentially toxic stormwater (containing forever chemicals, PFAS, carcinogenic pollutants, etc.) into the Deer Creek drinking water Aquifer.
We have a serious human health issue “brewing” in Edmonds on potential stormwater contamination of drinking water for southern Edmonds, Woodway and Esperance residents. The issue is accommodating potential development instead of avoiding health impacts caused by Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS)-contaminated drinking water.
During heavy rains the sediment traps get overwhelmed by high flows. The current temporary permit allows the city to clean the traps in advance of this fall’s rainy season. (Photo courtesy City of Edmonds)
There’s a new development in the decades-long tug-of-war between the City of Edmonds, the State Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW), environmental groups and adjacent property owners to balance flood control and fish passage on lower Perrinville Creek. The DFW has issued a limited temporary permit to allow the City of Edmonds to clear accumulated debris from the city’s existing sediment trap/overflow structures, with the aim of mitigating potential flooding during the upcoming rainy season. The permit expires on Jan. 13, 2026, and work must be completed by that time.
A vernal pool wetland at Turnbull National Wildlife Refuge in late May that is seasonally dry. The lighter, cracked soil has dormant seed shrimp eggs scattered on the surface. Forested wetland at Mission Creek Park in early AprilSame forested wetland at Mission Creek Park in early JulyPacific treefrogVernal pool at Palisades Park in mid-April
Did you know that many of Washington’s wetlands completely dry out most years?
In fact, most wetlands in our state appear dry during much of the year. You might not recognize them as wetlands but they still perform vital functions such as improving water quality, storing flood waters, and providing habitat.
Wetlands are areas where water is at or near the soil surface for at least a couple of weeks during the growing season. In early spring, Washington’s wetlands typically have ponded water or saturated conditions which affect the types of plants that can grow there. When conditions are much drier, the influence of water still shapes the functions and values of those wetlands. Although it can be hard to identify wetland areas in late summer when they may appear as dry as the surrounding areas, it doesn’t make them any less important as waters of the state.
Wetlands have important seasonal functions
The seasonal drying cycle is an important process for maintaining water quality. The transition from anoxic conditions—when the wetland is full of water and there is no oxygen in the soil—to oxic conditions when the surface of the soil is exposed to oxygen—results in chemical changes that help reduce pollution.
For example, nitrogen is a common nutrient that degrades water quality. The element is an important crop fertilizer that is also released from other human activities such as combustion from fires and vehicle exhaust. Excess nitrogen not taken up by plants can cause algae blooms. Wetlands help process excess nitrogen and reduce adverse impacts on other waters. The seasonal oxic-anoxic transition in wetland soils is a big part of how they process that nitrogen. An excellent overview of that process is available here.
Towards summer’s end, many wetlands appear dry, but are on stand-by, ready to perform valuable functions as the rainy season approaches. Wetlands absorb and store precipitation during the wetter months. This slows the flow of water to Washington’s streams and rivers, preventing flooding and erosion. It also helps to recharge underground aquifers and keeps the water flowing in our streams and rivers when the weather is hot and dry again. As water is detained and stored in wetlands, sediment and pollutants are filtered out, which helps to improve and protect water quality.
Forested wetland at Mission Creek Park in early AprilSame forested wetland at Mission Creek Park in early July
Seasonally dry wetlands offer safe haven for some species
Pacific treefrog
Wetlands that dry out are important places for some wildlife. These species rely on habitat where fish and other predators requiring more permanent waters cannot survive. Washington’s state frog, the Pacific treefrog, is a small amphibian living throughout the state. They have loud voices that often fill the night with their calls, or chorusing, in the spring. They are also a favorite meal for many predators. These frogs specialize in seasonally dry habitats where they can get in and out of the water without encountering too many species wanting to eat them.
Adult treefrogs lay eggs in the early spring when wetlands have standing water. Then their tadpoles race the clock to metamorphose into tiny frogs and leave the wetlands before the water is gone.
Vernal pools: a unique type of seasonally dry wetland
One wetland that typically dries completely is a vernal pool. These wetlands hold water early in the growing season and then usually dry out within four months. They host unique plant and animal species adapted to these conditions. Vernal pools are one of the most important habitats for waterfowl migrating through Washington in the spring.
In addition, several species of fairy shrimp and seed shrimp rely on vernal pools for their life cycles. These invertebrates are specially adapted to wetlands that dry out, with a dormant life stage that rests in the dry soil of vernal pools until water becomes available again in the winter. You can find vernal pools throughout the Channeled Scablands and Columbia Plateau, as well as the San Juan Islands.
Vernal pool at Palisades Park in mid-AprilSame vernal pool wetland at Palisades Park in late May
Whether you’re exploring the back country, taking a day hike, or walking in a local park this summer, see if you can recognize the wetlands in our landscape, even if they are dry. They will transform once again when the seasonal rain and snow returns.
Perrinville Creek after blockage. (Photo courtesy Edmonds Environmental Council)Perrinville Creek before blockage. (Photo courtesy Edmonds Environmental Council)
The Edmonds Environmental Council last week filed a complaint with the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife on what it says is the City of Edmonds’ “ongoing refusal” to restore fish passage in lower Perrinville Creek.
These concrete boxes are designed to catch sediment coming down Perrinville Creek during high flows. According to the Edmonds Environmental Council complaint, they also form an insurmountable barrier to returning adult salmon.
The Edmonds Environmental Council (EEC) on Monday filed a formal complaint with the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) against the City of Edmonds over what it maintains is an illegal diversion of the lower portion of Perrinville Creek that prevents the return of adult coho salmon.
The Edmonds Environmental Council is hosting a public workshop on critical areas in Edmonds from 7-9 p.m. Friday, July 18 in the Port of Edmonds Administration Building 2nd floor meeting room, 471 Admiral Way, Edmonds.
The EEC is hosting a Workshop, open to the public, on the City’s Critical Areas Ordinance (CAO). The results of the Workshop will be used to provide public input to the CAO update that the City must complete by December 31st as well as recommendations for a Critical Areas Program Amendment to the City’s Comprehensive Plan.
Workshop attendees will:
Explore what’s working and what’s not in protecting the City’s Critical Areas and the unique Edmonds environment.
Develop recommended Code revisions for the Critical Area Ordinance Update.
Develop recommended revisions to other City Code that affects implementation of the protective measures in the CAO.
Develop recommendations for critical area policies and a Critical Areas Program Amendment to the City’s Comprehensive Plan.
The City’s current Critical Area Ordinance, which will be referred to in the Workshop, can be found at https://edmonds.municipal.codes/ECDC/23 .
Contact us at: Edmonds.Envir.Council@gmail.com The Edmonds Environmental Council is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization that seeks to bring balance between needed development, environmental protection, and compliance with State laws. The EEC was formed in response to a growing need for “informed” voices to help educate residents and City officials on the perils of ignoring the human and natural environment.
The Edmonds Environmental Council (EEC) is filing a complaint with the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) on the City of Edmonds’ ongoing refusal to restore fish passage in lower Perrinville Creek. The EEC is alarmed that a City that touts support for salmon recovery in Puget Sound is allowing the eradication of salmon in one of its creeks. This is especially hypocritical because the blockage impacts the adult coho salmon that otherwise would be returning this fall to Perrinville Creek as part of a cooperative salmon restoration effort in Edmonds creeks.